ZLuC 2019 Salt Lake Attendees

Here are the folks that registered for ZLuC 2019 in Salt Lake.

  • Jenna Freedman, Barnard College
  • Lauren Kehoe, ZineCat
  • Matthew Collins, University of San Francisco, Gleeson Library
  • Kristin Alexander, Virginia Museum of Fine Arts Library
  • Deana Brown, Idaho Commission for Libraries
  • Erin Elzi, University of Denver
  • Gwyn Hervochon, Boise State University
  • Milo Miller, QZAP – The Queer Zine Archive Project
  • Lauren Brewer, Greensboro College
  • des alaniz, UC Santa Barbara
  • Paige Sundstrom, University of California, Santa Barbara
  • Donna Baluchi, Eccles Health Sciences Library
  • Jade Alburo, UCLA
  • Gina Murrell, University of San Francisco
  • Rose Rodriguez, Northwest Vista College
  • Stephanie Novak, Salt Lake County Library
  • Marie Paiva, Marriott Library, University of Utah
  • Katie Wegner, Summit County Library
  • Joshua Barton, Michigan State University
  • Erika Church, Marriott Library, University of Utah
  • Cassie Leclair-Marzolf, Salt Lake County Library, Sandy Branch
  • Kelsea Jones, Treasure Valley Community College
  • Claudia Maria Acosta, Travis Fristoe Zine Library at the Civic Media Center in Gainesville, FL/EXILE Books in Miami, FL
  • Tod Robbins, Independent friendly wizard
  • Rebecca Baker, The Salt Lake City Public Library
  • Rachel Getts, The Salt Lake City Public Library
  • Christina Walsh, The Salt Lake City Public Library
  • Becca Lael, Park City Library
  • John Ingersoll, Grantsville City Library
  • Ari Zickau, Boise Public Library
  • Jennifer Eltringham, University of Colorado Colorado Springs
  • Juli Huddleston, Grid Zine Fest
  • Eric
  • Sarah Morton Taggart, Grid Zine Fest
  • Jay Colbert
  • Stephanie Howell, Salt Lake City Public Library
  • Ricky Vigil
  • Hannah Waddel
  • Honor Moody, Harvard Library

Diversity and Inclusion

Saturday July 20

Breakout session 2, 12:15-1:00pm

Session name: Diversity and Inclusion

Facilitator: Matt C.

Note taker: Jennifer E.

  • Introductions
    • Topics that came up: 
      • Representation
      • zines as an educating force to expose young people to other perspectives
      • Curation & starting a zine collection
      • countering elitism/hegemony in art libraries
      • inclusive spaces
      • health disparities
      • shutting up & getting out of the way, using power to lift others up and create inclusive spaces
      • inclusiveness in makerspaces, generous exclusion – Marijel (Maggie) Melo
  • Building Safe Spaces
    • How to create safe spaces without policing people?
    • Responsibility of being an authority figure (in the classroom) – calling a bad action bad if you see it
    • Statement about a safer space, laying out expectations 
    • Code of Conduct – post it at your event, enforce it 
      • De-escalation training, have a point of contact for zine fest tablers to contact if they are in a tough/uncomfortable/violent/unsafe situation 
    • Community agreement – discuss parameters, give people buy-in by creating an agreement together.
    • Refer to Code of Conduct for this conference: http://zinelibraries.info/events/zine-librarian-unconferences/zluc-organizers-toolkit/#conduct
  • Inclusive Spaces
    • Librarian conferences are white spaces (librarianship is an 80% white profession) – conversations about diversity & inclusion are fraught, people often don’t know how to respond 
    • Embracing embarrassment and uncomfortable moments in order to move beyond mistakes
    • Lack of conversation
    • Diversity as a buzzword rather than an action and a practice
    • You will make mistakes, and we will talk about it as part of a community conduct agreement
    • De-escalation training as part of a conference like this, seeking out professional development opportunities
    • Reading circle to learn how to talk about race
    • Bystander intervention, using your voice to preempt violence when you see it 
  • Getting out of the way vs. speaking up
    • Doing the work but not being a white savior
    • Community partnerships
    • Explicit goals in collection development, strategic planning in general
    • Not expecting people from marginalized communities to be the only ones doing the work, while centralizing marginalized voices
    • Racist imagery in old yearbooks – endless meetings, lots of anxiety, no action
    • “Verbal asterisks” when showing historical objects in closed stacks & pointing people to resources
      • Context and information literacy are our jobs too!
      • Presenting without lecturing
    • Getting into leadership in order to make change
      • Again, not expecting PoC & marginalized communities to do the work, but using power 
      • Lip service vs. action

 

Debrief notes

Saturday July 20

Breakout session 3, 2:30-3:45pm

Session name: Debrief group time! All together now!

Facilitator: Rebecca

Note takers: Jenna, Lauren, & Honor

A ZLuC assessment will go out before too long. 

ZLuC has been going on since 2009

  • Everyone is part of it as much or as little as you want to be. 
  • Please follow up as you like, on the email list or however, all throughout the year. 
  • The community is open and meant to be welcoming. 
  • Hey, you can do this, in this remote community, but also in your own communities. 
  • Shout-out for POC travel grant. 

Loves (Jenna note taker)

  • Thanks organizers: got to see a lot of SLC, got to know it a little and how cool it is, what the zine scene is like x2
  • Thanks organizers helped people find housing, providing home stays, coordinating them
  • First conference where I didn’t actively think about leaving librarianship
  • Awesome mix of people who are experienced and people are new to zine librarianship. Thank you for sharing. 
  • Loved the program zine: space for notes, something to review later, inspiring and fun
  • Had a lot of fun
  • The idea of zine librarianship is relatively new, so excited that it’s something I can do
  • Gratitude, positive experience, glad boss let me come. 
  • Glad to have academic librarians to connect with. 
  • Meeting folks from all over, but also meeting librarians from nearby to where the ZLuC is hosted. Connecting with folks from region of where the unconference is hosted.  Friendship and accountability.
  • “Punk rock nerd camp” looks forward to it every summer, real-time interactions. Shit gets done. 
  • Being part of ZLuC has helped my project evolve as it has. 
  • This community, the connections I’ve made, amazing group of people. Love being part of it. Thank you all! Organizers especially. 
  • Appreciated vegan options at every meal and snack
  • Appreciated the existence of a quiet room, even if I didn’t use it
  • Loved having so many people who are not from SLC, seeing your interest in our city, taking time from your jobs and your lives to come here. (acknowledges preconceptions about Salt Lake City). 
  • My heart is full. 
  • Liked having a facilitator who set an agenda, shared it, etc. 
  • Outreach session was my favorite. 
  • Loved the zine reading and the Q&A with readers afterward, how they feel about having their zines in libraries. Great to have folks who are zine makers but not also zine librarians and zine fest organizers like we are. 
  • Inspirational that zine librarians are so willing to be ourselves, to share ourselves (be multiple selves). “It’s hard to be weird and a competent professional.”
  • Cool to get to know more about zines, and get to know more about unconferences. 
  • Public transit, especially from the airport

Takeaways (Lauren notetaker)

  • What the zine scene is like in SLC and how that can transfer to different communities
  • So many questions answered about zines in libraries and zine librarianship
  • Connecting zine creation with standards in k-12 education to get teachers more engaged in using zines in the classroom
  • Donate a zine to their collection and making copies to distribute
  • Inspired to do zine work in libraries.  Not just workshops, but throughout many aspects of job responsibilities
  • A lot of notes and ideas that are percolating 
  • Possibility of mentorship from people met at ZLuC.  Affinity/Interest group formation.
  • Energized from real time interactions.  Being in the same space together, shit gets done.  
  • Each ZLuC is special and unique, process for planning is iterative and ongoing.  Thinking about what can be coordinated in one’s hometown.
  • Favorite session was outreach and storytelling – how zines are the medium to tell so many different kinds of stories.  Tactile. Visual. Keep, save away, throwaway (recycle). Can be taken anywhere and shared with anyone. The work that we do in libraries, and as zine enthusiasts, we are the best advocates for this community.  
  • Great to connect with zinesters at the zine reading.  Important to not just talk to librarians about perspectives.
  • Experience of attending an unconference – anthropologist.  

Improvements (Honor)

  • Handouts of recommendations for facilitators; guidelines/how to/encouragement to participate
    • This could be a zine! ACTION ITEM!
    • Note takers Identify action items; spend 5 minutes at end of session and identify folks willing to take on action items
    • Establish goals for start of conversation, maybe better use of whiteboards
    • +1 for facilitators toolkit; 
  • Quick recap on first day about this is an unconference, this is what that means/context for owning your experience
  • One library has meeting standards/best practices posted in every room, does a quick check in before each meeting
  • Ice breaker on first day would have been a good way to ease into the conference, meet folks you might not be in sessions with
  • Contacts for attendees: Juli meant to do an attendee list, now she has an ACTION ITEM!
  • For attendee list: it would be helpful if folks could identify their area of interest
  • Housing was expensive; issue with multi-level marketing scheme convention jacking up all the prices–future organizers should be mindful of external events that might eff everything up; maybe the local tourist office could help with this?
  • Never made it to zine making space b/c so much other awesome stuff happening, but if it were more central, maybe they might have
  • Jargon dictionary zine to help bridge conversation between folks with tons of zine experience but less library experience/librarians with not so much zine experience
  • Acronym finder 
  • New articles for zinelibraries.info
    • Is anyone willing to take on this work? wrangling/delegating
  • Make zine at each as part of feedback; action items
  • Next year have program with cut outs for use in creating feedback/takeaways/words advice zine  
  • More consideration/programming for early career folks/students
  • More zine recommendations! Because we like reading things!

ZL(u)C 2020

Facilitator: Jenna

Notes: Honor

Better long term planning: announce two years out if at all possible

Maybe can’t make decisions here, but would like to have a conversation and get things moving

Also mini ZL(u)Cs–we are us, you can declare at will; we can be one or many (we contain multitudes!)

Community has tried to move around to different regions, not having too many in a row on one coast/on region

Violet Fox wants 2020 in Montreal, not clear what the details are, but should be nailed down soon

Discussion points:

Advantage to having organizers who have attended; but this may limit locations/limit to folks able to travel elsewhere

  • Local organizers have always had the option of asking past organizers; but didn’t necessarily realize it; can this be made explicit; 
  • Would be great if a current organizer had formal advisory role;
  • If planning 2 years out; possibly organizer elect; organizer; organizer advisor
    • Juli felt like Violet’s toolkit so awesome that this might be overkill

Accessibility:

  • Financial
  • Physical

Location considerations:

  • Extant zine culture?
  • What zine collections are in the city? 
  • Multi-institution vs. single space
    • Bureaucratic issues with larger institutions
    • Grid Zine Fest strongly embedded in community, so able to organize social events in conjunction with SLCP/Marriott Library; for Marriott, longer time line might have helped pushback against some bureaucratic stuff
  • Public transit super important
    • Especially from airport

Can we form a 2020/2021 deciding committee here? 

  • What is time commitment, when is it most intensive
  • Deciding committee process:
    • Criteria for being considered
    • Call for submissions
    • Assess submissions

Deciding committee:

Ari (2 years), Josh (either year), Juli (this year), and Matt (this year)

 

Archived sessions, Salt Lake

Friday July 19, 2019- J. Willard Marriott Library, University of Utah 

Breakout session 1:

Breakout sessions 2:

Breakout sessions 3:

Saturday July 20, 2019- Salt Lake City Library Main Library

Breakout Session 1:

Breakout session 2:

Breakout Session 3

Debrief– all together

edit-a-thon: zinelibraries.info

Saturday July 20

Breakout session 3, 12:15-1:00pm

Session name: Zinelibraries.info

Facilitator: Honor

Note taker: Jenna

Introductions

Tags and categories:

General organization; 

Examples of zine collection donation forms; examples of zines as handouts 

Juli is working on acquisition forms:

Something about libraries should buy zines when possible, but forms can help library folks catalog/ process/ etc their zines

  • Creator contact info
  •  How the creator can contact the library (in case of future changes, or requess for take down, etc)

Forms located (confirm with libraries for permission)

Soapbox http://www.phillysoapbox.org/donate/zine-donation/ (author and non-author)

Barnard: https://zines.barnard.edu/zine-donations

QZAP:

Google form to collect feedback; 

Some find the site confusing, seems to be less so when logged in

Questions for Violet:

Are categories pre-planned, or based on tag usage?

Social action

Saturday July 20

Breakout session 2, 11:15-12:00pm

Session name: Social Action

Facilitator: Milo 

Note taker: Juli 

Zines as tools in activist communities

Why? Why Make Zines in Times of Strife (And Calm) http://zinelibraries.info/2017/04/06/why-make-zines/

 

  • Zines as health literacy to combat bad info in other zines
    • How do we deal with changing information (QZAP example about HIV/AIDS zines that are from the 90s)
  • Where do (institutional) libraries fit in radical social action? 
  • Do libraries need to be politically neutral? Presenting information on the sly, which zines to put into the collection. Do other folks feel the need to do zine stuff in a politically neutral space?
    • Social action can be under the radar, it can be secret. 
    • Information professionals have information– you can direct folks to other resources. To the radical info shop, etc. Find those sources– link them to zine makers if you know them
    • When teaching information literacy, give students the tools to vet out bad information
  • Showing students potentially dangerous materials to help them understand why people make decisions they do
  • Curation as social action– $supporting$ people zine makers who are actively practicing social action
  • Cataloging as social action– reframes how knowledge is structured in the future
    • The act of cataloging zines makes one aware of the problematic nature of Library of Congress Subject Headings
    • Spurs you on to think more about social action
  • Starting a zine libraries is a radical act
    • Having insider knowledge from zine makers to help infor cataloging
  • What to do with hate speech zines? Keeping them for historical purposes, but not glorifying them. Maybe/ probably not in the browsing collection– but is there an archives that would be a good home for that in order the keep for research. 
    • This all depends on your collecting policy.
    • Keeping the perspectives of the other side, which helps illustrate why zine makes are fighting against. Zine makers are counter-culture– they can’t be viewed in isolation. 
    • Revisit and revise your collection development policies! This is not static! <3
      • Check out https://zinelibraries.info/code-of-ethics/
      • Don’t prioritize shitty zines (including if the zine makers are problematic/ abusers/ etc)
      • Come up with a protocol with how to deal with shit
      • Reach out to communities that are affected, and let them guide you from
    • Buy zines from POC zine makers and amplify their voices

zine fest planning

Saturday July 20

Breakout session 1, 10:15- 11:00am

Session name: Zine Fests!

Facilitator: Jenna

Note taker: Juli

First time organizers

Boise Comic Arts Fest August 24-25! 

Curriculum integrated zine fairs

Call to tabling forms

Accessibility

Reaching out beyond people you know

Zine fest fails

Fundraisers

Community partnerships

Equity and  justice

Money

Asking for money

Financial transparency

Table fees

Community partnerships

Accessibility and equity and justice

Call to tabling forms

Outreach and promotion

Fails:

  1. Workshops during tabling time doesn’t work for lots of tablers
    1. Solution: table swingers– volunteers to cover table shifts
    2. Solution: Separate day
    3. Keep in mind: it makes it more accessible for folks who can’t spend money
  1. Taking on too many responsibilities (afterparties, not enough organizers)
    1. Solution: Afterparties- let someone zine adjacent plan the party and host, no one is required to go.
    2. Solution: not an after party, but hosting vegan brunch
  1. Volunteers: 
    1. Solution: special tee-shirt just for them 
    2. Solutions: Make explanations clear, explain before things get hectic

Tabling form, outreach, and promotion:

  1. How to specify what kind of materials you want there
    1. 75% rule (or whatever percentage– some use 50%)
      1. Do you police this?! 
        1. How to not seem like the gatekeeper
        2. Clear about intention, explain that non-zines are taking the space of someone else’s space 
          1. Suggest other locations for tabling
      2. People get nervous about whether or not they qualify
        1. Titles and prizes
        2. Links (?)
        3. It is okay to only have one zine!
    2. Checklist on material types, so tablers understand what is a zine
      1. Let zine makers self-identify
      2. Zine fest is not the same as ComicCons

Accessibility, equity, justice:

  1. How to make the audience more diverse
    1. What is the connection with community partnerships
  2. MKE Zine Fest scholarship
    1. Wasn’t successful the first year (no one applied)
    2. Tried again, with more success
    3. Push outside zine/punk/alt communities– school, church, work, etc to reach a new audience
  3. Check outreach notes from yesterday’s sessions
  4. If you have a code of conduct make sure you have de-escalation skills
    1. Designate and person to be “security” 
    2. Take a deescalation workshop/ webinar
    3. Book recommendation, “Make Spaces Safer” AK Press, Shawna Potter
  5. Kid friendly flags
  6. Free tables for folks that can’t afford it

Money/ Fundraising:

  1. Ask for what they want. If you have an institution, ask for a budget
    1. Don’t be afraid to ask for donations
  2. Are other zine fests posting their finances on their websites?
    1. Should zine fests be more transparent
    2. Would it help other zine fests?
  3. Table fees: Usually covers the entire
  4. “The Art of Asking,” Amanda Palmer

Call for tabling forms: send them to juliahuddleston (at) gmail.com, and she’ll post them to zinelibraries? 

Programming with Adults

 Saturday July 20

Breakout session 1, 10:15- 11:00am

Session name: Programming, incl. exhibits, programming with people with limited English skills – without teens

Facilitator: Matthew

Note taker: Lauren

Introductions and why are we here?

Programming — Ideas, Ideas, Ideas

  • Working with ESL patrons.  Bringing in content written in other languages
  • Working with refugees
  • Language barriers, variety of languages
  • Finding zines in different languages.  
  • Representing different voices and perspectives
  • Area studies librarians at some schools are 

Round of sharing good programming ideas

  • Workshops each semester, open to all.  Small crowd attendance. https://guides.usfca.edu/zines/events 
  • Location of workshops → away from zine collection into the lobby
  • Mini zines, binding workshop.  Simple pamphlet stitch. Halfway there.
  • Collaborative zine.  Not a lot of contributions the day of, but over time collected content. Then used for outreach.
  • Social Justice heroes on campus.  Get students to create zines about them.  Templated pieces: interview, pasting, collaboration, librarians fill in as needed. 
  • How is program promoted, “sold,” to potential participants.  → All about bringing awareness to zine collection, with a goal to start a club with students or patrons to take leadership for the zine collection.  Work with professors for instruction (rather than programming).  
  • Tabling, fairs.  “De-stress week” and “consent fair.”  
  • Collaborative zine → can be made over time, i.e. combining contributions to the zine from different events and make a yearly zine or a zine for the semester.
  • Collaboration with external partners, i.e. youth tribe or girls rock camp, etc.  Intro to zines, then whatever you put on the page is your zine. Librarians collated contributions to the zine and then gave to the group at the end of the week.
  • Turnout can be low with college students.  Hold events off campus to be more inclusive, but there’s a lot of components
  • What kind of thematic content are events coordinated around?  Meaning could be just getting people together to let them know that the collection is available.  
  • What kind of supplies are used?
    • Typewriter
    • Gluesticks
    • Markers, pens
    • Book sale poaching or recycling bin salvaging
    • 8×10 paper
  • Do programs provide supplies?  One page with name, contact info, and consent to use the zine or created content.  
  • Failures:
    • Too much programming → mini zines, stitching, collaborative zines.  
  • Who are the zines from the programs distributed to?  Consider the permissions and acquiring consent from participants
    • Attendees?
      • Pickup later
      • Send to them
      • Take at the time of workshop
    • Kept in library?
    • Circulated more broadly.  
  • Passive programming → have a table, basket, area where one can put out zines and other materials to make zines and they can create their own, take supplies, contribute their zines
  • Zine Kits for checkout
    • Scissors,
    • Tape
    • How to make a zine
    • Glue sticks
    • Typewriter if available
    • Other supplies
  • Zine Cart
  • Assignments to make zines.  Sometimes through collaboration with faculty → do a workshop, assignment to make a zine, history of zines, students might reflect through the zine and / or prepare materials to begin/make their zine.  
  • Readings of zines (inspired by last night’s social event)
  • Invite a local distro in to give a guest workshop/talk/presentation
    • Donated copies of their zines to the library
  • Screening of $100 and a tee-shirt
  • Jennifer Eltringham, Instruction Librarian, UCCS Zine about lesson plans for incorporating zines into coursework

Exhibitions

  • Special collections “Flash” exhibition.  Showcasing some zines.
  • Physical or digital exhibitions
  • Topical 
  • Browsing collection → two stations by an exit that are themed and this increases circulation of the browsing collection
    • Self care
    • Banned books
    • Indigenous Authors
  • Showcase books on zine history and zine making to promote the zine collection.  90s music playlist.  
  • Gallery display case → move around the case to different places in the library.  
  • Sculpture display using mylar plastic cases where zines were showcased and in the middle of the library → University of Minnesota Architecture library https://www.continuum.umn.edu/2017/09/zine-collection-inspiring-assignments-art/ 

 

Archives

Friday July 19

Breakout session 3, 2:30- 3:45pm

Session name: Archives, primary source documents with zines, zines as primary source

Facilitator: Deana

Note taker: Juli

Public lib collection, but may be moving more archival

Local history class/liaison with Hist Dept

Funding with Teaching with Primary Sources, Lib of Congress

How are people using zines as a primary sources?

  • History of the Book course- the professor is connected to the library, and is enthusiastic about Special Collections. Zines are a week in this course (along with the comics collection)
    • This brings in the history of zines, perspectives that zines bring to the table
    • Talks about ethics of having zines in the library
    • Students relate to/ identify with zines in ways they might not with other history of books
  • In the public library zines are viewed as ephemeral, and it is hard to connect the dots that zines are worthy of being kept and have enduring value
    • Had to bargain that in order to catalog the collection, they had to weed the collection. But sent it to the local university, to be archived
  • “Sneaking” zines into other instruction methods– make zines on the same level as other materials like newspapers, letters, etc
  • Pairing decolonization zines with letters from early missionary efforts (colonization). How do these items speak to each other, and how are the effects felt across space and time?

 

  • How to bring zines into the archives when the students can’t get to the archiving. Digitized zines! QZAP is a great resources 

 

  • Zines as a way to remix archives! (in the same vein as the subversive nature of zines)
    • AMAZING zine “Whatever Happened to Emma Crawford?” using the primary sources, telling the story, a way to pitch to professors
    • Could be applicable as a public history session (or a way to engage with the public and make them interested in history)
    • This zines uses primary sources, but zine-i-fies them (see pictures)
    • Using zines to allow buy-in in the archive, to empower folks to visit the archives, or feel ownership of the material
    • To get folks to relate to a zine, they need to feel connected
      • How to use perzines as a valuable story
        • Programming
  • Feelings around using zine makers who are still alive, being used in the classroom. Would someone be weirded out by this?
    • RADICAL EMPATHY– feminist ethics of care. The archivist has an affective responsibility toward their users, donors. Who should an archivist be responsible and sensitive to? (Zine makers)
    • How do we consider the creator? Taking items out of the collections
      • Shifting the idea about keeping everything. We can’t and we really shouldn’t try. If someone wants to be forgotten, that is their right. It’s tricky to navigate. Zine creators probably don’t have a claim to having the item removed, but archivists have a higher ethical obligation. 
  • How to acquire older zines, locally? 
    • Build a relationship with zine people and ask, buy or donate. 
    • How to talk about institutional trust with punks and DIY community
    • Be sure to reach outside your circle. 

 

Outreach and promotion

Friday July 19

Breakout session 3, 2:30- 3:45pm

Session name: Outreach and promotion

Facilitator:

Note taker: Claudia Acosta

#3 OUTREACH

Partnerships outside academic institutions

Working with community based orgs, best practices

A memo of understanding: if someone leaves your library, a point of connections, so that when someone leaves it doesn’t drop

Setting up expectations and guidelines in partnerships

A problem: 2 totally diff ideas of what that partnership entails

Alphabet soup for queer youth in SLC experiences:

Had a negative experience recently, afterwards worked out an application for them to fill out so that we know exactly what they’re going to be saying and doing, share with them your expectations 

Giving teens guidelines on how to treat each other, respect guidelines, signing it — sharing it with them so that they know those expectations

 

Q: how to reach out to potential community partners?

Asking what can we do for you? What do you want out of this? What are your expectations? Create space for them to frame what the opportunity can look like, let them tell you

Pay attention to *their* organizing and community building, look for gaps in their programs, offer something they’d be interested in or on their radar, up to the library to recognize needs and framing it as an educational opportunity

Establish trust! Anti-establishment zinesters are going to be skeptical.

Q: outreach opportunities? For public x academic librarians

Academia reaches out to students, should also reach out to professors ‘hey, this is a tool you can use!’

What does this outreach look like in an academic setting? Different departments in your university.

Who is in better touch with the students than we are? – student organizations

Faculty! Come to us for instruction! Maybe you’ll find more interest+engagement by engaging with a zine about chemistry? Learning tools!

Outreach from a medical librarian perspective: Correcting zines with medical misinformation, so much of it is wrong!!!

Zines about reproductive health — planned parenthood! Listing and sharing resources

Bring your varied interests into the forefront of what you do — bringing in your own interests and letting that guide you at least initially.

A form of outreach: social events organized for after this conference! Grid fest fundraiser and readings!

Examples of outreach: 

Teen creative writing competition

summer camp collars with kids

Code of conduct zine — advising had reached out to someone to help them make it, so that’d be easier to read

Greensboro zine fest has a good relationship with the food co-op, they invited GZF into their space, making zines about food insecurity, community zine workshops at the co-op

Zines as staff development tools. ex. Reading groups with staff-selected topics — let your colleagues know about zines!

Go to zine fests!

Taking zines out of the library — pop-up at the local pride fest, spring time zine workshop at a local greenhouse

collaborations with grade schools, relationships with principal and their own media specialists

A Library flooding incident — you *had* to leave the library! Those partnerships became all the more important. Collabs with the food pantry at a local high school

Miami Zine Fair outreach to Haitian immigrant community: integrating ourselves into existing programming instead of imposing ourselves on them; hosting a zine fair at a community center and inviting those involved in teaching classes at the community center already to be involved. Example: Caribbean dance performance during zine fair. 

 

Zine Union Catalog part 2

Friday July 19

 

Session name: Zine Union Catalog part 2

Facilitator:

Note taker: multiple [ella, milo]

FROM ZINECAT – YAK (session 2)

Hack plans

  • GitHub
    • Lauren will clone to ZineCat https://github.com/lsrkthelibrarian/zinecat.org
    • get accounts (lauren to set up)
      • Personal setup
      • Then, access granted
    • Getting data from Milo’s, Jenna’s, Lauren’s
      • Harmonize
    • Proofing front-matter
    • this all will set us up for communication post-zluc
  • Data cleaning/metadata mapping
    • get some data, start cleaning
    • get map into GitHub
  • Budget brainstorm
  • Governance

————————————

Overview of https://github.com/lsrkthelibrarian/zinecat.org

Issues tab is where much project management lives

  • Question about notifications

Explanation of CollectiveAccess functions

Next next steps

[see above image]

Normalizing GitHubs

Move metadata map 

  • w/ Milo describe this document

Governance & Decision-making process (Jenna updating in the document)

  • Forecasting budgets

Read-through of existing documentation

Budget forecasting subgroup (Milo and Ella)

  • Basic costs
  • Things that cost money that we want
    • Domain registration
    • Server space
    • Mirrored hosting (pay twice but don’t go down)
    • Security certificate 
    • UX, accessibility
    • Catastrophic service
    • External consulting
    • Legal consulting 
    • Accounting consulting
    • People wrangler
    • Sys admin: CA, 
    • Head cataloger
    • Whiskers cat
    • CRM human
    • Documentation writer, maintainer
    • Swag, outreach
    • Meet-up expenses
  • Coop model
    • Do members contribute money?
    • Do members contribute time? 
    • Do some of the consultants come from the membership? 

Milo’s breakout group notes

ZineCat Preliminary Budget Doc

What are we spending money on?

  • Hosting

    * Domanin Registration

    * Annual Web/Domain Hosting, server space, DB space, etc

    * Mirrored Hosting

    * Security Certificate

    * Backup Service

  • Development

    * CA Dev work

    * UX/UI Accessibility

    * Maintenance Service (SLA)

    * Catastrophic Service (Hit By The Bus Scenario)

 

  • External Consulting

    * Disaster Planning

    * External testing for accessibility

    * Legal

    * Accounting

 

  • People Powers (NOT Human Resources :P)

    * System Admin (CA)

    * System Admin (Server Infrastructure)

    * Head Cataloger (Ingest)

    * Whisker Cataloger (De-duper/Data Cleanup)

    * CRM Humyn

    * Documentation Keeper

 

  • Marketing (Swag)

    * Stickers

    * T-shirts

    * Tote Bags

    * Trucker Caps

 

  • Meet-up/Conference/Real-time Space Sharing

 

Instruction

Friday July 19

Breakout session 2, 11:45- 1:00pm

Session name: Instruction

Facilitator: juli

Note taker: des

Questions/topics for convo

  • Instruction as a librarian and archivist, also as a professor maybe???
  • Developing a session with school teacher librarians on incorporating zines
  • Teen librarians working with librarians in middle school and high schools
  • Outreach to instructors about how to use zines in the classroom, what benefits are
  • Pedagogy and zines, using zines in one-shots
  • Zines as tools for staff development and building communities of practice
  • Zine workshops for teens, kids. Working with education dept at the arts museum
  • Zines and info literacy instruction in higher ed
  • Exploring zines in one shots

Working in K-12 settings

  • What does successful engagement look like? Teen Zine Team! Zine club/zine making is integrated into library programming
  • Partnering with zine fests and other community orgs to publicize
  • Bringing in materials and letting folks have at it. Working towards zine fest in october
  • Having themed sessions provides just enough structure
    • Offering folks option of contributing to collabo zine or doing their own thing
    • Other opportunities to circulate/publicize/promote zines (pop up exhibit, etc)
  • Having folks bring completed zines to zine club, offering ten copies straight up and 15-20 if they donate a copy
  • Introducing zines to students; how do you convey zine-ness
    • Using minizines instead of handouts (lots of work but folks in university context seem to like)
  • Students don’t really know what zines are great starting point for talking about zines honestly
    • Ambiguity about zines is pretty awesome; bringing hella examples helps
  • Engaging with print culture is not familiar to students
    • Bringing in the original ugly copy to demystify the process
  • Take em to the collection!!! Share what you love
  • Being open about your personal story with zines helps, 

Zines in Higher Education Settings

  • Raising awareness about cool shit in archives, demystifying archives
    • Storytelling and finding one’s voice
    • Including zines in archives and archival one-shots
  • How to get faculty buy in using zines in one-shots
    • Building relationships with faculty
      • If folks are assigning creative projects/posters/infographics
    • Normalizing zines as a type of material/resource in one-shots
    • Info literacy instruction
    • Informally talking to people about zines
  • Building support and visibility amongst library staff: maybe you are the point person for zines but everyone should know what they are and how they can benefit library
  • People who don’t see value in using zines in instruction contexts means a convo needs to happen with that person. Can’t win over everyone but initiatives that bring visibility to zines and zine collections can demystify process for staff too.
    • Personal experience with zines is hella important

Zines as assignments

  • Clear rubrics for what content is on what page
  • You can’t  force someone’s creativity or how they express that
  • Gallery walk on last day of class to view each other’s work, talk about their zine, highlight sections
    • Not just finished product but can the student articulate (verbally or otherwise) what their goals were, what pages mean to them
    • Looking at student’s work individually

Natural allies to be found in gender studies, but what about STEM classes?

Using Info Lit standards

Zines as collection; example of a medium type

Making zines

 

TEMPLATES ON ZINELIBRARIES.INFO

Instructional zines

Zine Union Catalog part 1

Friday July 19 

Breakout session 2, 11:45- 1:00pm

Session name:  Zine Union Catalog- Yak

Facilitator: Lauren, Jenna

Note taker: Ella

CUNY GC ZUC updates – Lauren

  • 5 minute history of the zine union catalog
  • Fall semester – annotation play with catalog and collective access
  • Independent Study – focused on project management and identifying 
  • Open Leaders

CUNY GC capstone – Jenna

Plan hack – Eric

Oreos

Twitter permissions

History:

  • 2009 the conversation begins
  • How/platform/what
  • 2013 – xZinecorex metadata standard
  • CUNY graduate program work
  • Collective Access (CA) platform
  • ABCNoRIo, Qzap, Barnard, Carnegie, Sallie Bingham others represented in prototype
  • Still tinkering with prototype as time allows (zinecat.org)
  • Time to push to build the ZineCat out
  • Lauren researching what needs to happen to take next steps, project management (GitHub?), connect to Free and Open Internet initiatives, outreach opportunities

Capstone:

  • $1000 grant money – hack in NY in October
    • original ask was 2 day CA workshop (more $$$)

Priorities for the last year of concentrated action on ZineCat:

  • Building the cat
  • Funding
    • Hosting
      • Openflow hack can pay for a year of server
    • GitHub add-ons
    • traditional cooperative model?
      • equal and fair share funding
      • equal voice is critical
      • dependencies on large contributors are problematic
      • Labor vs. money
    • What budget do we need?
      • Pay for someone to ingest
      • hosting costs
      • come up with a 5-year budget
  • Project Management
    • GitHub https://github.com/lsrkthelibrarian/zinecat.org 
      • Can we do not just tech with the platform? how to introduce people to that
        • Communication to clarify the use and powers of the platform
        • Documentation
          • Draft of a readme (lauren)
      • Even experienced developers have a hard time doing anything but submitting code on GitHub
        • GitLab, ZenBench – adding on top of the platform an interface for discussion (none of which are free – charge per person per month)
          • Lab.citycrm.org
        • Other interfaces could still be hosted/paid – maybe better fee structures for our purposes?
  • Community Engagement, 
  • Universal Design, 
  • accessibility, 
  • governance structure/shared decision making
    • where are we at with this? is this work useful?
      • Mostly Jenna and Lauren up to now – looking to generate more community involvement
        • Deciding on governance structure would be hugely useful
      • Pilot governance determined at ZLUC 2018 – should we just put this forward?
      • “Y’all who have been doing this work – go ahead, we trust you” (the community, via Milo)
    • Hosted on a server paid for by CUNY grad program which will expire
      • Need to find another university host
        • Lack of trust in a university as hosting entity
      • Or simply pay for something (Qzap model)
        • Different types of institutions are sharing information, so let’s not prioritize one source/contributor over another

—————————————————

  • Round of sharing our thoughts/feelings/ideas/etc or pass:
    • Choices are mostly unstable in regards to funding streams.  Come up with five year budgets (a few options: minimal, viable, thriving etc.) Help us set priorities 
    • Big picture:
      • Budget development mentorship possibilities
      • intentionality about skill-building
    • How do we write documentation to get more stakeholder investment
      • clear writing
      • map for future work
    • What would it look like if we didn’t have to have this funding discussion
      • More open ideation, let’s not get stuck in the budget
    • Infrastructure, tools, budget
      • Seminar to make money for the project – turn our skill building into an income stream
    • Keep discussions ongoing between now and the next unconference, keeping input and commitment coming in
    • Institution buy in without more power
      • one-time sponsorship vs co-op share
      • being able to say “yeah, we’ll take your money” to large/moneyed groups
    • Lurker perspective, data-supplier
      • stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (endowed? foundation funding? some sustainable income stream)
    • Creating a zine library foundation, building out an endowment model
        • inherently hierarchical governance structures, how to get past that
          • ABCNoRio as an example to investigate
      • ZineCat
      • ZLUC
      • More events and projects
      • Nonprofit umbrella for small zine libraries
    • Wikidata for zinelibraries (Honor attending Wikimania)
      • current and historical

Hack talk

  • GitHub
    • Lauren will clone to ZineCat
    • get accounts (lauren to set up)
      • Personal setup
      • Then, access granted
    • Getting data from Milo’s, Jenna’s, Lauren’s
      • Harmonize
    • Proofing front-matter
    • this all will set us up for communication post-zluc
  • Data cleaning/metadata mapping
    • get some data, start cleaning
  • Budget brainstorm
  • Governance

zine collections

Friday July 19

Breakout session 1, 10:15- 11:30am

Session name: Zine collections

Facilitator: Kristin Alexander       Note taker: Des Alaniz

Guiding questions for this session?

  • Talking to folks about starting a new collection
  • Sharing about starting a new collection
  • How do other folks circulate their collections?
    • Participating as a zine library at a zine fest in san antonio
  • How to Display them?

Circulating and Archival collections

Making the choice that circulating collection will have some loss/damage, but access is important

Getting buy-in from catalogers and tech services folks

Providing folks with guidelines for cataloging

Richmond Museum of Fine Arts (Virginia context): role is half acquisitions, half cataloging, all this is in one role in addition to other duties

  • Buy in from tech folks here looks like sitting with the cataloger and explaining what they are doing
  • Putting collections into worldcat; zines circulating, none of the other holdings do
  • Financial buy in is important
  • Cataloging part is a struggle

Intern/curator/librarian to pre-catalog zines, do rich text descriptions of zines that catalogers can map to a MARC record or whatever

Taking as much cataloging information as possible from the zinesters themselves, communicating that process to folks donating zines to the collection. 

Being responsive to zine makers is essential!

  • Creating a good zine donation form-half page on who we are, what we want to do with the zine
  • Taking donation from the university and from students also requires informed consent 
  • Zine cataloging events!
  • Talk to Jenna F about cataloging and intern program!
    • Intern can create basic record and be reviewed by catalogers/tech services
  • Creating a zine that includes “What we will do with your zine” to take to local zine fests
    • Zine compensation- if you cant use institutional funds or resources, just making zines to trade can help
  • Having to go through acquisitions to purchase zines
  • Distributor to libraries (Oh Boy Comics)
  • Collecting zines that are not written in English

Sharing these zine donation forms, etc online (thru zinelibraries.info?)

Commissioning zines as a collection from local artists

Supporting artists by buying everything you can

Raising funding to start a collection

A little goes a long way; not having a budget can be useful “just keep buying”

Being given too much and not being able to spend it isnt a good look either

Community suggestion form for acquisitions

Collection Development Policy impacts this

-at an art institution, focusing between book arts and zines is the priority. When you go in that direction they tend to be more expensive (proximity to artists’ books)

-looking at campus DEI office for mini grants and such; looking for other pots of money on campus to support the collection

-focusing on specific areas while also accepting donations from all over

-connecting collection scope to faculty research areas, student interest, library DEI goals or instruction missions

-chapbooks, bound books o zines are hard to draw distinctions on as part of “zine” collection

If zinester calls it a zine, it’s a zine!

-purchasing two copies of zines: one for archive and one for circulation

Organizing and cataloging collections

-alpha by title

-alpha by author (allows for collocation by author)

-LC call #’s allow for zines to be retrieved alongside other works but creates problems also. Still housed together at least!

-archival collection is in a finding aid (as a manuscript collection)

-at simmons: collection is on its own, with a three letter code for category (activism=ACT) and a cutter number for title

-@ art museum, zines are one of few things not in closed stacks

– how are patron folks are searching? Are ppl using the catalog for discovery or browsing IRL?

-anyone with experience having a zine collection that circulates in a library of items that doesnt? How much do people use them at the library? Could have a manual check out system

-folks concerned about circ stats? If folks are browsing how do we track use?

Depends on what admin is using for justification: defining success and how it is measured

-blue shelf on every row to place browsed items; do not reshelve!!!!

Two boxes: i read and i liked, i read and i didnt like!

-zines requested for instruction sessions with art faculty

-demonstrating that zines are not a “weird” collection but also belongs in a library and is another form of material culture

FUTURE PROJECT: Collecting forms, policy statements, etc and creating  shared drive for collection policies, zine donation forms etc

Labeling zines?

  • -Zine collection sticker (designed by zine libs!) placed on each item
  • -barcode on the exterior folder
  • -putting tattle tape on the board/comic book stiffener
  • -important to mark as a library item
  • -labeling so that folks who may not be super familiar with collection can also reshelve them proper

Volunteering with ALA zine pavilion: email zinepavilion@gmail.com

Antagonistic patrons re: zines?

  • People trying to censor collections
    • Form for folks who have issues that goes to admin
  • Intentional collecting on “controversial” topics; waiting for possible blowback but also knowing you have admin support is big
  • Zine scavenger hunt! Find a zine with X in the collection (good programming idea haha)
  • Having a review process for hate speech in donation and collections
    • Getting author contact to get bg on what zinester was thinking
  • Other zine librarians: reinventing the wheel, stepping on toes

Including one’s own zine in the collection? No major issues

 

Zines in storytelling

Friday July 19

Breakout session 1, 10:15- 11:30am

Session name: Zines in Storytelling

Facilitator: rebecca

Note taker: ella

present: jennifer, lauren, rebecca, stephanie, kelsey, stephenie, 

participant interests/ideas:

Making zines bigger part of job

Intergenerational learning and programming

spoken word to written word

storytelling vs. art zine community

students reading/creating

teen librarians, queer youth

sharing zines with people that need them most

Discussion:

Experiences working with patrons, getting them to tell stories through zines?

  • Storytelling for college-age freshmen
    • found it challenging, storytelling feels unfamiliar to the group
  • getting past the barrier of “i would never tell somebody this,” or the visual tropes of zines
    • use creative writing prompts
    • allow free exploration of zines
    • access to materials
      • zine clubs: magazines, glue sticks, everything you need; plus examples of zines
        • materials budgets/photocopying: what can you get away with? what can you ask for from your institution?
          • setting up a parameter, ex: once a month bring in what you’ve finished and we’ll make ten copies for you. This also allows for your institution to know what to expect
          • the importance of the final product
  • Students intimidated by the process
    • scaffolding in experiences
    • community zine (workshop at acrl)
  • Respect for the power dynamic
    • being vulnerable, but also being at work
    • not asking students to put themselves at risk through the assignment
  • With teens but would also work with freshmen: 
    • list of expectations – stories stay in the classroom, not grading them on the story told, but on the effort
  • Intergenerational activity – interview elders and those with various life experiences
    • teen homeless shelter creative writing workshop – participants wouldn’t talk about themselves, but interviewing others in the workshop was very successful
    • youth and elders communicating
  • Not just consumers of media, but also creators
  • How to make storytelling safe for “at risk” creators?
    • list of expectations, signing a behavior contract (both facilitators and participants)
    • takes time to build relationships
    • For teens: no parents allowed
    • Public librarians have facilitator roles, not as much authority figures – more neutral figures
  • Full storytelling safety is not really possible in a classroom
    • But conveying to students that “its ok to care about a subject” is helpful, combats detachment and challenges with academic voice
  • Student run clubs (may be unsanctioned)
    • useful for expression, can also be risky depending on content
  • Safety of having community member-created zines out in a library where the rest of the community has access
    • pseudonyms, identity, anonymizing oneself
    • internet and information privacy talks relevant here
    • pre-internet zines vs new zines
    • “A Story” vs. “That specific person’s story”

Storytelling Prompts:

  • have you ever seen a ghost
  • have you ever seen a ufo
  • grossest food you’ve ever eaten
  • most exotic place you’ve ever traveled to
  • Collaborative dis-orientation guide: What do you wish you had known when you started?

Passing around samples of zines, storytelling

Sharing your story, your story is your own and no one can take it away

Storytelling is something that makes zines powerful and magical

They can be anything, and your story fits into the format